Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

I've been reflecting on the ethics of library engagement with their vendors. When I published Red Light Green Light a year ago, I was thinking about how to take back control of the materials budget. But there are other angles as well. For example, if you read reviews on GlassDoor of various vendors, you see common themes, for example of strategic change, reorganizations, layoffs, and other cutbacks. There are also cases that are more disturbing. It's probably not possible to draw conclusions about a company as a whole from any single employee review, but sometimes you see fairly specific and apparently widespread allegations of, in one case, gender inequities, harassment, and discrimination. Do librarians consider issues of this type in licensing or other engagement with vendors? Should they?

Comment

Sounds like someone's writing something...

 ‎· Meg Vmeg 2
12 more comments
Comment

Answers: no, and no. I don't see how journal/ebook/etc vendors are different from other vendors our institutions deal with. If the institution has applicable standards regarding contracting then of course those could be used. And to the extent that we chat with our reps, I suppose if your rapport allows it you could ask about these rumors and offer sympathy. Otherwise I generally assume that the organizations we deal with are plagued by the pathologies common throughout the US; that the sales reps in for-profits are regularly abused by superiors driving them to hit their targets, and that the non-profits are relying on low-level employees with crappy benefits in NYC or wherever who are willing to work for a cool company that needs to underpay them in order to balance massive salaries "competitive with the rest of the industry" to top-tier execs. This is not the same problems you mentioned above but it's the same wheelhouse--do we need to feel good about the companies we're contracting from. It would be great if we could. But, that way lies madness. Better to focus on how well the products they are peddling serve our users.

 ‎· Jiffy Kurls 3
Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

I was impressed to learn about the hard line tactics that BTAA and other consortia took with T&F earlier this year. Is this more typical but just not widely publicized? https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2018/08/15/advocating-change-btaa/

Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

Ithaka S+R published a new report today, Amplifying Student Voices, which is collaborative research with a group of community colleges on students' needs. In the second half of this IMLS-funded project, we will be looking towards how college libraries can best support these needs. The project is authored by my colleague Christine Wolff-Eisenberg and NVCC's Dr. Braddlee. http://sr.ithaka.org/publications/amplifying-student-voices/

Comment

Our VP just sent me and my dean a link to the Inside Higher Ed article on this... I wouldn't say there are any surprises in it but it's good for such things to be supported by research.

 ‎· Jiffy Kurls 1
Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

Excellent piece today from our own @lisalibrarian arguing that licensed resources are over utilized and offering strategies for driving down usage to expose real value https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2018/05/22/are-library-subscriptions-overutilized/

Comment

Thanks for sharing this @rschon. It's been quite a day replying to comments from the publisher community. The librarian community has been really positive about the ideas though.

 ‎· LisaLibrarian
6 more comments
Comment

I think what emboldens libraries is the sense that users will somehow get what they need without the library subscription. It isn't SH, Green, etc. specifically emboldening libraries - it is that users won't march on the building with torches. :) oh, and also, most of the emboldened have promised fee free ILL/doc delivery for anything scholars need. Reading the websites and not just the press releases is helpful. Having said that, I would note as well that a lot of the more aggressive stances are in Europe and the proposals are to replace a subscription Big Deal with an APC Big Deal so I'm not sure that librarians are being emboldened in all cases so much that they are negotiating for something different. Which, in honesty, I believe the publishers will be okay with once they can work out the financial model. Of course, I also believe they are trying to figure out an RIAA-like threaten-to-sue approach but can't figure out how to make that work ... yet. So, who knows? I do think that the RG lawsuit is potentially the real black swan event here depending how it is decided.

 ‎· LisaLibrarian
Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

News Corp Chief Executive Robert Thomson called for the creation of an “Algorithm Review Board” to oversee tech giants and provide a check on their increasing power. He has been critical of Facebook Inc. and Alphabet Inc.’s Google, saying they have too much influence over the news and information consumers see and offer little insight into the workings of their platforms.

Comment

https://www.wsj.com/articles/news-corp-revenue-lifted-by-real-estate-and-book-units-1525988515

 ‎· Roger
Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

Big news today: Springer Nature IPO postponed "The planned initial public offering of publisher Springer Nature has been postponed on the eve that trading in shares was expected to begin "due to market conditions"." https://www.thebookseller.com/news/springer-nature-ipo-postponed-782656

Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

Our own @aarontay presenting today at CNI on a panel facilitated by @lisalibrarian n The Privileged Link: Open Access, Version of Record, or Let the User Decided? #cni18s

Comment

Yay!

 ‎· bentley
4 more comments
Comment

Thanks @rschon! @Aarontay - you did a great job ... I'm really pleased with how the whole panel came together and it was a really great discussion with attendees.

 ‎· LisaLibrarian 2
Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

I decided to write a couple pieces on how research workflow investments will affect those scholarly publishers at risk of being "left behind" -- and what they can do about it. I think this suggests some of the implications that will arise for universities and their libraries, but I envision writing something specific with them in mind as well. https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2017/12/18/workflow-strategy-left-behind-context/

Comment

Here is part 2: https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2017/12/19/workflow-strategy-left-behind-options/

 ‎· Roger
Avatar for rschon
» posted to Roger and lsw

Libraries Look to Big Data to Measure Their Worth—And Better Help Students https://www.edsurge.com/news/2017-11-17-libraries-look-to-big-data-to-measure-their-worth-and-better-help-students

Comment

“University libraries are having to explain their place in the world of degree completion,” says Alan Bearman, dean of university libraries and the Center for Student Success and Retention at Washburn University. “As we all know, there’s this big push in the nation about on-time degree completion, and libraries are trying to see where they fit in that world.”

 ‎· secret agent Fister
Comment

No more losing yourself in the stacks!

 ‎· secret agent Fister 1
Comment

There are other worlds we should fit into, also. But y'all know how I feel about that.

 ‎· secret agent Fister
Avatar for rschon

I've come to like the expression "more wood behind fewer arrows" - the idea of needing to bring prioritization and focus given that time and resources are always limited. But, I've been wondering if this phrase might be offensive or irritating in any way? Your thoughts?

Avatar for rschon

If there is no traffic, do navigation apps estimate your arrival time based on the posted speed limit - or your historical driving speed? .

Avatar for rschon

Barbara Hammer Archive adds to Beinecke's collections of LGBTQ creativity https://t.co/OnU5B5sCqF .

Avatar for rschon

"Serves on the Reference Desk…in order to obtain first-hand knowledge of the needs & problems of student & faculty… https://t.co/M9GhblGJFS .

Avatar for rschon

Job opening: University Librarian, University of Hawai'i https://t.co/DSlC6MYmsI .

Avatar for rschon

Including a short discussion of this @GaviaLib piece https://t.co/UjvQfLJlvv .

Avatar for rschon

Thread on diversity "residency" programs, including some key avoidable problems. @jvinopal @SoulCitySigma https://t.co/IBT9ndHlhU .

Avatar for rschon

Powerful and troubling. @MartinKurzweil @wpnick https://t.co/ewXQAqpT4u .

Avatar for rschon

To improve diversity, talent, and culture, library leaders must first look inside their own organizations and pract… https://t.co/2Pq0jrIppX .

Avatar for rschon

Job opening: Director, @metmuseum https://t.co/cx4ApQWYsk .

Comment

Finally, a way to waltz in to that place without feeling guilty about not paying anything for the suggested admission. jk.

 ‎· Stephen Francoeur 3
Avatar for rschon

Chicago's municipal ID can also be used to pay public transit fares and to use the public library! https://t.co/avwRTTGKrG .

Comment

And I hear that they announced this to the press before they told the branch libraries!

 ‎· hedgielib 2
Comment

@hedgielib: Oh jeez. Nice one.

 ‎· Roger
Avatar for rschon

Students are "abused" transferring credits from community colleges to bachelor's degrees @dougledIHE via @LexaLogue https://t.co/RyFRy0yxei .

Avatar for rschon

Wonderful generosity from the Stavros Niarchos Foundation benefiting @nypl & all New Yorkers. @infodocket https://t.co/SF8CfzZJux .

Avatar for rschon

Big news from @MellonFdn: Earl Lewis to step down as president https://t.co/eKxu9OwgCy https://t.co/h8CzYT3Goq .

Avatar for rschon

Thrilled to see my recent @IthakasSR post on @OSFramework & research workflows appear in Portuguese on @RedeSciELO https://t.co/KYNzPUhHT2 .

Avatar for rschon

Johnetta Cole to serve as @MellonFdn fellow, focusing on art museum diversity, accessibility, equity, & inclusion https://t.co/Gs99SlD0DN .

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10